THE BAGELS
Hand-rolled. Kettle-boiled. Baked fresh daily.
🎉 NEW LOCATIONS COMING SOON: Bradenton, FL and Sarasota, FL
New York's Legendary Bagelry™
A TASTE OF NEW YORK, RIGHT HERE IN FLORIDA.
Family-owned since 2001. Authentic New York bagels, breakfast, deli favorites & catering across Florida.
- Kettle Boiled & Baked Daily
- Pick up & Delivery
- Premium Catering
MORE THAN A BAGEL SHOP
New York roots. Florida grown. Family built.
Since 2001, Stuff-A-Bagel has been serving authentic New York-style bagels, stacked breakfast sandwiches, deli favorites and more. What started as one family-owned bagel shop has grown across Florida without losing what made us special in the first place; fresh food, familiar faces, and a commitment to doing things the right way. No freezer, no shortcuts, Real NY flavor.
Read Our StoryNEW YORK’S LEGENDARY BAGELRY
THE BREAKFAST
Fresh-cracked eggs. Premium ingredients. Made to order.
THE DELI
Boar’s Head meats. Stacked sandwiches. NY-style favorites.
THE CATERING
From 10 people to 1,000+, we know how to feed a crowd.
See What's Coming Out of the Oven
SINCE 2001
The Same Bagels People Have Been Coming Back For Since 2001
Twenty-five years later, the recipes haven't changed. Neither has our commitment to serving the bagels and deli favorites our customers know by name.
Why Florida Keeps Coming Back
★★★★★
They have the very best Bagels we have found in the Fort Myers and Naples area. We were able to pre-order Rye bagels which are almost impossible to find locally. Their Blueberry and Cinnamon/Raisin are also the best we have found. Plus an order of a dozen nets you fourteen.
Michael Bedwell
★★★★★
Super New York vibes. Spectacular food, excellent service, and the place in fitting of Disney Magic. The location is awesome and super convenient for anyone looking for a jump start to their busy day!
Brian Ramos
★★★★★
Cape Coral's BEST bagels, best location, best customer service !! And the Jersey Turnpike is the best around, no other bagel joint even comes close.
Mark Simon
Visit Us
Loading map...
Windermere | Orlando
13211 Reams Rd, Windermere, FL 34786
Today: 05:00 AM - 02:00 PM